top of page
Search

Screen Printing vs DTG vs DTF vs Embroidery for Custom Apparel

Nov 7
10 min read

Meta description: Compare screen printing, DTG, DTF, and embroidery for custom apparel. Learn how artwork, fabric, texture, durability, and order size affect the best decoration method for your project.


Social sharing excerpt: Two custom T-shirts can feel completely different because the decoration method matters. Here’s how screen printing, DTG, DTF, and embroidery compare, with real-world examples from BKNY PRINTING in Brooklyn, NYC.


Two T-shirts can have the same logo, the same color shirt, and the same size print, but feel completely different when you wear them.


One might have a soft, washed-in graphic that feels like part of the fabric. Another might have bold ink sitting on top of the shirt. A third might show full-color artwork with a smooth transfer feel. A fourth might not be printed at all, but stitched with thread for a raised, professional finish.


That difference is not random. It comes from the decoration method.


At BKNY PRINTING in Brooklyn, NYC, custom apparel projects often start with the same question: should this be screen printed, printed with Brother GTX DTG, decorated with DTF, or embroidered? The right answer depends on the artwork, garment, budget, timeline, order quantity, and how the apparel will be used.


Screen printing, DTG, DTF or embroidery? Learn which custom apparel method fits your project with expert tips from BKNY PRINTING in Brooklyn, NYC.


Close-up view of custom T-shirts with different print textures on a worktable
Different decoration methods create different textures, finishes, and wear characteristics.

The quick comparison


Here is the simple version before we get into the production details.


Method

Best for

Texture and feel

Artwork style

Common order fit

Screen printing

Bulk T-shirts, workwear, events, simple brand graphics

Ink sits on or slightly into the fabric, feel varies by ink and coverage

Bold logos, spot colors, limited-color designs

Medium to large runs

DTG printing

Small runs, detailed art, full-color cotton shirts

Soft feel, especially on lighter garments

Photos, gradients, detailed illustrations

Small to medium runs

DTF printing

Full-color logos on many garment types

Smooth transfer feel with some stretch

Full-color artwork, small details, mixed materials

Small to large runs

Embroidery

Hats, polos, jackets, uniforms, premium apparel

Raised thread texture

Clean logos, text, patches, simple marks

Small to large runs


There is no single “best” method for every job. A contractor ordering 100 work shirts has different needs than an independent clothing brand testing 12 designs. A restaurant uniform program has different wear conditions than a fitness studio launch drop.


Screen printing is the classic choice for bold, repeatable designs


Screen printing uses a mesh screen and stencil to push ink onto the garment. Each ink color usually needs its own screen, which means setup matters. Once the job is set up, though, screen printing becomes very efficient for larger quantities.


That is why screen printing is still one of the most practical choices for custom T-shirts, staff shirts, event merch, and brand apparel.


When screen printing makes sense


Screen printing works especially well when the design has solid colors and clean shapes. Think:


  • A restaurant logo on the left chest and back

  • Contractor shirts with a company name, phone number, and service area

  • Fitness studio event shirts with a bold front graphic

  • Business shirts for a team, conference, or grand opening

  • Independent clothing brand graphics with strong linework


For a restaurant ordering black T-shirts with a one-color white logo, screen printing is often the right lane. The print is bold, repeatable, and cost-effective as the quantity goes up.


For contractors, screen printing is also a reliable option for high-visibility work shirts, long sleeves, and hoodies. Simple artwork tends to print cleanly, and larger runs help spread out the setup cost.


Artwork requirements for screen printing


Screen printing likes clean artwork. Vector files are ideal, such as AI, EPS, or print-ready PDF files. High-resolution raster artwork can also work, but low-resolution screenshots and tiny JPEGs often need cleanup.


The number of colors matters. A one-color print is simpler than a six-color print. If the artwork has gradients, shadows, or photographic detail, the file may need halftones or another method may be a better fit.


Texture, durability, and garment compatibility


Screen printed ink can feel soft or more noticeable depending on the ink type, garment color, print size, and number of ink layers. A small left-chest print may feel barely there. A large solid rectangle may feel heavier.


Durability depends on proper production, garment choice, wash care, and use. A well-produced screen print can hold up very well for repeated wear, especially for work shirts and uniforms. Like any decorated garment, washing inside out and avoiding high heat helps extend the life of the print.


Screen printing works on many cotton and cotton-blend garments. Some performance fabrics, stretch fabrics, and specialty materials need specific inks or testing.


DTG is strong for full-color detail and small custom runs


Direct-to-garment printing, usually called DTG, prints ink directly onto the fabric. BKNY PRINTING offers Brother GTX DTG printing, which is well suited for detailed designs, full-color graphics, and lower-quantity orders.


DTG is often the right choice when the artwork has many colors and the customer does not want to pay screen setup costs for each color.


When DTG makes sense


DTG is a good fit for:


  • Independent clothing brands testing a new graphic

  • Artists printing detailed illustrations

  • Small business shirts with full-color artwork

  • One-off or short-run custom T-shirts

  • Photo-style prints on cotton garments


For example, an independent clothing brand may want 24 shirts with a large, detailed illustration on the front. Screen printing that same design might require several screens, separations, and setup time. DTG can often handle the detail more directly, especially when the garment is compatible.


A fitness instructor selling a limited run of full-color event shirts may also choose DTG if the artwork has gradients, texture, or photographic elements.


Artwork requirements for DTG


DTG works best with high-resolution digital artwork. PNG files with transparent backgrounds are common. The better the file, the better the print has a chance to come out.


Low-quality artwork is still a problem. DTG does not magically fix pixelated logos, blurry screenshots, or tiny images pulled from a website. If the image looks rough on screen at full size, it will likely print rough too.


Texture, durability, and garment compatibility


DTG prints tend to feel soft because the ink goes into the garment fibers rather than sitting as a thick layer on top. On light cotton shirts, the feel can be especially smooth. On dark garments, pretreatment and white ink are usually involved, which can affect the hand feel.


DTG usually performs best on 100% cotton or high-cotton garments. Blends can work, but results vary. Performance polyester is usually not the first choice for DTG.


For durability, DTG can hold up well with the right garment and wash care, but large prints on heavily washed shirts may fade over time in a way that feels more like a worn-in graphic. That can be a benefit if the goal is a softer fashion look.


Eye-level view of a DTG printer producing a full-color graphic on a black T-shirt
DTG is useful when artwork has full-color detail and the garment is a good match.

DTF is flexible for full-color logos and mixed garments


Direct-to-film printing, or DTF, uses a printed transfer that is applied to the garment with heat. Instead of printing directly onto the shirt, the design is printed onto film, prepared with adhesive powder, and pressed onto the apparel.


DTF has become popular because it handles full-color designs and works across a wide range of garment types.


When DTF makes sense


DTF is practical for:


  • Business logos with multiple colors

  • Restaurant uniforms on T-shirts, hoodies, or aprons

  • Fitness studio apparel with stretch and movement

  • Contractor apparel that includes shirts, hoodies, and safety gear

  • Smaller orders with full-color artwork

  • Designs that need consistency across different garment types


Say a Brooklyn cafe needs 15 T-shirts, 10 hoodies, and 12 aprons with the same full-color logo. DTG may not be ideal for every item, and screen printing may not be efficient if the quantities are split across garments. DTF can be a useful option because the transfer can be applied to many compatible fabrics.


For fitness studios, DTF can also make sense for logos on performance tees, cropped sweatshirts, and tote bags, depending on the material.


Artwork requirements for DTF


DTF handles full-color artwork well, but clean files still matter. Transparent PNG files and vector artwork are both useful. Fine lines, small text, and distressed details need a careful look before production.


Very tiny lettering can fill in or become difficult to read once transferred. A print shop should review the design at actual size, not just zoomed in on a screen.


Texture, durability, and garment compatibility


DTF has a smooth transfer feel. It is usually more noticeable to the touch than a soft DTG print, but it can be very practical when the artwork or garment type calls for it.


DTF works on many cotton, polyester, and blended garments. That makes it useful for mixed orders, especially when the same design needs to go on different apparel styles.


Durability depends on the transfer quality, press settings, garment surface, and wash care. Like other decorated apparel, high heat drying and harsh washing can shorten the life of the design.


Embroidery gives apparel a raised, professional finish


Embroidery decorates apparel with thread instead of ink. The design is digitized into a stitch file, then stitched directly onto the garment or onto a patch.


It has a different purpose than printing. Embroidery is not always the best choice for large, detailed artwork, but it is excellent for logos, names, uniforms, hats, polos, outerwear, and premium merchandise.


When embroidery makes sense


Embroidery works well for:


  • Restaurant polos, aprons, caps, and jackets

  • Contractor hats, fleece jackets, and workwear

  • Business uniforms and staff apparel

  • Fitness studio quarter-zips, bags, and caps

  • Independent clothing brand hats and small logo placements


A restaurant may choose embroidered caps and aprons for front-of-house staff, then screen printed T-shirts for kitchen or event staff. A contractor might use embroidered hats and jackets for a polished look, while screen printing larger back designs on work shirts.


That mix is common. A full apparel program often uses more than one decoration method.


Artwork requirements for embroidery


Embroidery needs digitizing. That means the artwork is converted into stitch instructions. A regular image file is not enough on its own.


Clean, simplified logos work best. Small text, thin lines, gradients, and tiny details can be difficult to stitch clearly. If a logo has lots of small elements, it may need to be simplified for embroidery.


Texture, durability, and garment compatibility


Embroidery has a raised thread texture. It feels premium and dimensional, but it also adds weight and stiffness to the decorated area. That is fine on hats, polos, jackets, and sturdy garments. It may not feel right for a large design across the front of a lightweight T-shirt.


Embroidery is known for strong wear performance when matched with the right garment and stitch density. The garment itself still matters. Thin, stretchy, or delicate fabrics may pucker if the design is too dense.


How order quantity affects the best choice


Quantity can change the best method quickly.


For one shirt or a small test run, DTG or DTF often makes more sense than screen printing because there is less setup. This is common for samples, custom gifts, artist merch, and brand testing.


For medium runs, the decision depends on the artwork and garment. A 36-piece order with a one-color logo may be great for screen printing. A 36-piece order with a full-color photo may be better for DTG or DTF.


For larger runs, screen printing often becomes more cost-effective, especially with simple artwork. Once the screens are set up, producing more pieces can be efficient.


For uniform programs, embroidery and printing often work together. A business might order embroidered polos for managers, screen printed tees for staff, and DTF logo hoodies for seasonal use.


Matching the method to real projects


Here is how this plays out in everyday apparel orders.


Restaurants


A pizza shop may choose screen printed T-shirts for staff because they need quantity, comfort, and easy reordering. Embroidered caps or aprons can add a more finished look for customer-facing roles.


Contractors


A construction or home service company may use screen printing for high-visibility shirts with a large back print. Embroidery works well for hats, jackets, and polos worn during estimates.


Fitness studios


A studio may want soft DTG shirts for a limited member drop, DTF tanks for performance fabrics, and embroidered beanies or bags for retail items.


Businesses


A company ordering apparel for a team event may choose screen printing for simple designs and larger quantities. For smaller full-color logo orders, DTF can be a practical choice.


Independent clothing brands


A brand testing new artwork may start with Brother GTX DTG or DTF for short runs, then move winning designs into screen printing when demand grows.


FAQ


Which printing method is best for custom T-shirts?


The best method depends on the design, shirt fabric, quantity, and desired feel. Screen printing is great for bulk orders and bold designs. DTG works well for detailed full-color artwork on cotton. DTF is flexible for full-color designs on many garment types. Embroidery is best for stitched logos on hats, polos, jackets, and uniforms.


Is DTG better than DTF?


DTG is not automatically better than DTF. DTG prints directly into the garment and can feel very soft on cotton shirts. DTF works on more fabric types and is useful for full-color artwork across mixed garments. The better choice depends on the apparel and artwork.


What lasts longer, screen printing or DTG?


A properly produced screen print can be very durable, especially for bold designs on compatible garments. DTG can also last well with the right shirt and care, but it may fade more like a soft vintage-style print over time. Wash care, fabric, ink coverage, and production setup all affect longevity.


Where can I get custom apparel printed in Brooklyn, NYC?


BKNY PRINTING offers custom apparel decoration in Brooklyn, NYC, including screen printing, Brother GTX DTG, DTF, and embroidery services. The team can help match your artwork, garment, and order size to the right production method.


Can I use more than one decoration method in the same order?


Yes. Many apparel programs use a mix. For example, a business might order screen printed T-shirts, embroidered hats, and DTF hoodies with the same logo. This can give each garment the right finish instead of forcing one method onto everything.


Get the right print for the right garment


Choosing between screen printing, DTG, DTF, and embroidery is not just a technical decision. It affects how your apparel looks, feels, wears, and fits your budget.


If you already have artwork, BKNY PRINTING can review it and recommend the best production path. If you are still deciding on garments, the team can help you think through fabric, placement, quantity, and finish before anything goes into production.


Ready to start your next custom apparel project? Request a custom apparel quote from BKNY PRINTING and get expert guidance on the best decoration method for your order.


 
 
 

Comments


For Quotes, Questions, & Design

Inquire Within: 

info@bknyprinting.com

Our showroom is open 5 days a week:

BY APPOINTMENT ONLY

Monday - Friday  10 am - 5pm

87 St Nicholas ave Brooklyn NY 11237

​

Follow Us

 

  • White Facebook Icon
  • White Instagram Icon
  • X
  • White Tumblr Icon
  • White LinkedIn Icon
  • White YouTube Icon


BY APPOINTMENT ONLY | CONTACT US: 718-875-4219

 

PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS & CONDITIONS | INFO PACK                                                                                               

© COPYRIGHT 2024 BKNY PRINTING               

bottom of page